The Greens “Big Reveal” that a rent-to-own scheme will solve our housing shortage suits the party of recycling & global warming. It’s just old hat reheated.
Co-leader Marama Davidson announced yesterday that the Green Party is ready to negotiate its rent-to-own policy as part of the Government’s Kiwibuild reset.
I would have liked to see some original thinking, but the Greens rent-to-own scheme is just old news that’s been around for decades, if not longer.
Rent-to-own, or rent-to-buy, came in a dozen different versions and in a previous life I used them all.
They had other names as well, such as option-to-buy, long-term agreement for sale and purchase, lease-to-buy, wraps, or even leases with options-to-buy.
In the 60s and 70s I put literally thousands of struggling people into homes for as little as $5 deposit in one case, and monthly payments the same as market rent.
Over the 5-year term a portion of their market rent was credited towards the agreed fixed price. By the end of the term enough money had been accumulated for people to refinance with a regular bank.
On the rare occasion they could not refinance, I would refund the “deposit” they had accumulated. Why not? It was easy to resell the house and start a new deal.
The only important stipulation I made was that the buyer must pay the rates and insurance and maintenance on the property. In my mind this was vital because how else would a buyer under the scheme really know how much it cost to own their own home?
To this day I still get Christmas cards from people I assisted so long ago and frequent greetings from people in the street, and sometimes even their grandchildren, thanking me for the assistance I gave.
Only a month or two ago I was in a shop when a staff member fell all over me in gratitude for helping him into a house in Herne Bay. I was very pleased – sort of – when he reminded me that I had sold him the property under a rent-to-own arrangement for $11,500 and today it’s worth $2.5 million.
Davidson says, “Being in secure housing allows you to put down roots, join a community and give back. New Zealand has been relying on a market approach to provide things a market cannot and never will provide.”
I have news for Ms Davidson: The people I put into homes in the 60s and 70s under a rent-to-own agreement were all done of my own free volition under a free market approach. Categorical proof that a market approach can work and has worked to provide a roof over your head.
So good luck to the Greens, whose policy sounds very much like the NZ First housing policy.
But remember folks, rent-to-own is a very old technique that’s been well and truly done before.
If the Greens – or any party for that matter – want some advice on the finer points from one who’s ‘been there, done that’, I would be only too happy to oblige. The need is greater that my political preferences.
[Photo by Jeffrey Czum from Pexels]
This content is provided for general information only and should not be relied upon or used as a basis for making any investment or financial decision. To the extent that any information or recommendations in this content constitute financial advice, they do not take into account any person’s particular financial situation or goals. As individual circumstances differ, we strongly recommend you seek independent legal and/or financial advice prior to acting in relation to any of the matters discussed herein. Neither Newland Burling & Co Ltd nor Provincia Property Fund Management Ltd nor any person involved in this content accepts any liability for any loss or damage whatsoever may directly or indirectly result from any advice, opinion, information, representation or omission, whether negligent or otherwise, contained in this content.